Mauricio Pochettino Man Utd: Manchester United sacked Michael Carrick after their worst start to a top-flight season since 1986/87. One win in 10 Premier League games leaves them 18th, one point above bottom club Crystal Palace and 10 off the top four.
United have conceded 19 league goals, and their 30 across all competitions is the heaviest toll in Europe’s top five leagues. Against Aston Villa on Sunday, they trailed 2-0 after three minutes and 40 seconds, then needed stoppage-time goals from Joshua Zirkzee and Patrick Dorgu to rescue a 4-4 draw.
The problems stretch beyond the pitch. Captain Bruno Fernandes blamed the staff’s tactics after a 4-1 defeat at Como, saying the refusal to mark man-to-man left space behind the press, while Lisandro Martinez pressed the technical director for more signings.
Into that mess steps Mauricio Pochettino. The United States head coach has reached a verbal agreement in principle, with a release clause worth £7m, and could sit in the away dugout at Anfield on 22 November. Three reasons suggest it won’t work.
Mauricio Pochettino Man Utd: 3 warning signs
1. He needs time United don’t have
Sky Sports notes Pochettino often struggles early at new clubs. He left Chelsea in May 2024 after one season and a sixth-place finish, though he has called it “not the right fit”. BBC Sport expects him in post by 19 November at the latest, which leaves days to organise a side that keeps conceding early.
2. His press needs a defence United lack
His best Tottenham sides pressed high and hard, reaching the 2019 Champions League final, but that style asks a back line to defend spaces. Martinez saw red at Chelsea after conceding a penalty, and striker Benjamin Sesko is out until January, so Matheus Cunha and Fernandes keep dropping off as false nines. He does develop young defenders, but nobody repairs a back four in one training week.
3. His record with hierarchies is patchy
Fernandes and Martinez have already criticised the people above the head coach. Reports in 2018 described him as frustrated by Tottenham’s tight wage structure and Daniel Levy’s reluctance to sell unwanted players. He also signed a United States contract in August that runs past the 2030 World Cup, then agreed a verbal deal with United within about three months.
Is Pochettino the right appointment for Manchester United?
No, and timing matters as much as personality. United need somebody who can stop a side from conceding in the opening minutes, and Pochettino’s methods take months to bed in. The club treats the manager as the cure for a structural problem, and Pochettino’s front-foot pressing needs a settled defence that United don’t have.
Martinez’s complaint about signings points at Wilcox’s department, and a defence that has leaked 30 goals needs centre-back cover and a screening midfielder in January more than fresh ideas. Eddie Howe, Antonio Conte and Julian Nagelsmann were all reported as alternatives, and Conte, who won the league in his first season at Chelsea, brings the defensive discipline United lack.
If INEOS insist on Pochettino, they must give him a say in recruitment and patience through a bad December. Ten points off the top four, United have little room for a manager whose first months resemble a rebuild.














