Manchester United spend the international break 18th, with eight points from ten league games and one win. No United side had sat in the bottom three in the Premier League this late in a season since 1986, Opta says. The 4-4 draw with Aston Villa captured the problem: Michael Carrick’s players recovered from two goals down twice yet conceded twice within four minutes. United began the season with twelve games without a clean sheet, their longest such start since 1930-31.
The summer rebuild ignored that weakness. INEOS spent on Carlos Baleba, Andrey Santos and Youri Tielemans left Luke Shaw without a recognised understudy and let Rasmus Højlund join Napoli, while Benjamin Sesko has spent much of the autumn injured. January needs three repairs, and these would do it best.
1. Nathan Collins gives United a leader at the back
Brentford’s 25-year-old captain sits on a Daily Mail shortlist of centre-backs. At 6ft 4in, with 154 Premier League appearances and 40 Ireland caps, he handles both a high line and a low block, which suits a side caught running backwards. He is right-footed, though, while United have chased a left-sided option, and he collected five league yellow cards last season. Brentford, who tied him to a deal until 2029, reportedly valued him at £55m earlier this year.
2. David Raum solves the left-back problem
The 28-year-old Germany international’s Leipzig contract expires in June, and TeamTalk reports he would cost about £30m in January and has greenlit a move to Old Trafford. He scored three and set up six in 27 Bundesliga starts last season, according to FotMob. His aerial numbers sit well below most full-backs. Shaw has made five appearances so far, and United see Patrick Dorgu as more of a left winger.
3. Jean-Philippe Mateta offers a striker on a deadline
The 29-year-old Crystal Palace striker is keen on Old Trafford and has shown little interest in extending a deal that expires in June, according to talkSPORT. He scored 16 times in 50 games last season, including the Conference League final winner against Rayo Vallecano, and ranks high among league strikers for aerial duels won. Injuries trouble him. Meniscus damage ended a January move to AC Milan, and a hamstring problem limited him to 92 league minutes by mid-October.
Manchester United New Signing: Which signing should Manchester United make first?
Collins comes first, even at £55m. Twelve games without a clean sheet is a structural failure rather than a goalkeeping blip, and no other name here addresses it. Pochettino needs a centre-back who organises the line when the front four commit forward, and Collins has captained a team that defends in several different ways. Fulham’s Calvin Bassey would cost less, but he gives up three inches in the air.
Raum comes second. A £30m left-back with six months left on his contract improves a squad whose cover at left-back is makeshift, and it lets Dorgu play higher up the pitch.
Mateta should wait. He can agree a pre-contract from January and join for nothing in July, so spending January money on a 29-year-old with a knee history makes little sense if Sesko returns. If Sesko does not, a short loan beats a fee for a striker United can claim for free.














