Nicky Butt reveals why Alejandro Garnacho struggled with Chelsea, and the player
Alejandro Garnacho ran into serious problems at Manchester United because his ego got in the way of his development before the move to Chelsea. Nicky Butt recently shared that the youngster arrived with an attitude that quickly distanced him from the rest of the academy.
Even though the Argentine winger clearly had talent, his refusal to stay grounded caused real friction in the dressing room. Butt believes Garnacho saw himself as a superstar long before he had actually proven it with consistent performances. As a result, Ruben Amorim told the winger he should look for a new club during the final game of last season.
This tension came to a head when the player publicly complained about not playing enough, despite not meeting the tactical standards expected at Old Trafford. Butt argues that the legendary United squads of the past would have pushed Garnacho much harder in training to keep his ego in check.
Since the current setup lacked those strong leaders, the club decided to let him go to protect the team culture. The numbers back this up: Garnacho had only a few goal involvements in his final months, making it easier for the coaching staff to prioritise discipline over raw potential.
“He signed at 16. I was academy manager at the time, and he signed a deal where they also signed Alvaro [Fernandez]. Garnacho was always a bit stand-off-ish; he had a high opinion of himself. I thought he had an edge about him. And when he got into the first team, I will just say what I think because I was there, he got above his station way too quick. He got superstar status way too quick.
“And that’s not a former player saying they get paid too much, I hope young players get paid millions, but he got superstar status too quick and he obviously scored the phenomenal bicycle kick.
“Someone in that club or team at the time should have been swatting him down, and they might have been, and he ignored them. But the best thing Man United did was sell him because, forget his ability, and I don’t think he is that great anyway, but I thought his attitude was a disgrace when he was at Man United.
“More importantly, when he left, and if you completely disrespect your team-mates and the football club when you leave, then that’s it.”
Good News for Gunners – Arsenal have a massive advantage in €45m Serie A deal
“It is common knowledge that [Amorim] told him on the final game of the season that he can go find a new club.
“If he had been in our team then he would have been taken out every single day in training with the players we were brought up with.
“He would have been treated really badly, he’d have learned from that and got better. He was 21 or whatever when he left the club but you can’t be up your own backside thinking you are as big or bigger than Man United.
“In an interview recently, I watched it and he said ‘I thought I should have played every game’. I was thinking: ‘number one, you weren’t even that good and, number two, you are young, be humble’. “What I would say is that he was very mentally strong … that’s his biggest strength and that is why every now and again he will do something unbelievable. He has massive belief in himself.”
Man Utd close to completing £43.5m transfer of Bundesliga midfielder
The cultural clash at Stamford Bridge
While London offers a fresh start, the details of the transfer suggest his attitude is still a major concern for any technical director. Reports indicate that Chelsea took a risk on the winger’s pace, but they are now dealing with the same personality traits that frustrated Nicky Butt. Because the youngster expects to start every game, Liam Rosenior has to find a way to develop him without upsetting a crowded squad.
