Manchester United sacked Michael Carrick on 12 November with the club 18th in the Premier League, eight points from 10 games and no clean sheets all season. The cruel part is that the attack did its job. United have taken more shots (193) and created more chances (144) than anyone in the division, yet they have conceded 19 league goals, with only Crystal Palace and Ipswich Town leaking more. A 4-4 draw with Aston Villa, who scored twice within four minutes, showed how loosely this back line plays.
Injuries explain part of it, with Matthijs de Ligt only just back after a year out and Luke Shaw, Lisandro Martinez and Noussair Mazraoui all missing games. Recruitment explains the rest. United spent the summer rebuilding midfield and left the defence for 2027, a call the Daily Mail’s Chris Wheeler describes as a costly misjudgement.
Martinez has now publicly criticised the hierarchy, director of football Jason Wilcox in particular, which makes a January exit likely. Harry Maguire and Shaw are also out of contract in June, so the whole unit needs fresh options within months, whoever replaces Carrick.
Three names keep surfacing in the reporting, and they differ sharply in how realistic they are.
1. Calvin Bassey, Fulham
Fulham’s captain turns 27 in December, is left-footed, and plays centre-back or left-back, covering two problem areas. He has more than 100 Premier League games behind him, and TEAMtalk reported United’s interest on 30 October. His weakness is aerial work, where FotMob ranks him poorly among centre-backs this season.
2. Jarrad Branthwaite, Everton
Everton’s 24-year-old stands 6ft 5in and matches the physical, left-sided profile Football Insider says United want. The Daily Mail reports an £80m asking price, and he signed a contract to 2030 last year. Hamstring trouble ruined last season, and he has made only eight Premier League starts this term.
3. Micky van de Ven, Tottenham
The 25-year-old Dutchman is 6ft 4in, quick and left-footed, and Football Insider calls him United’s top target for 2027. He signed a deal to 2031 in August, and Tottenham have no intention of selling mid-season. He also missed their opening game with an undisclosed issue.
Manchester United new signing: Which defender should Manchester United prioritise in January?
Bassey is the sensible signing, and the reason is timing rather than glamour. United can talk to him from January and might sign him free in the summer, but Fulham hold a one-year option, so waiting could leave United paying anyway. Market-value estimates sit around £21m, a fair price for cover at left-back and centre-back while Martinez heads for the exit.
Branthwaite is the better player to build around and the wrong January deal. Paying £80m for a defender who spent most of last season injured, before United even know who their next head coach is, would repeat the summer’s habit of buying without a plan. Revisit him in June, once the new manager has chosen a system.
Van de Ven is a distraction. Tottenham hold every card, and chasing him wastes weeks.
With three defenders potentially leaving at once, a cheap, flexible signing now protects the summer budget for the centre-half who actually matters.














