Manchester United player ratings vs Manchester City make for a grim reading after United failed to beat ten-man City at Old Trafford. Phil Foden saw red in the 23rd minute for kicking out at Bruno Fernandes, handing the hosts a huge advantage, yet United never found the cutting edge needed to turn pressure into goals.
United had more of the ball after the dismissal, but City stayed compact and waited for a mistake. Erling Haaland struck in the 60th minute from Josko Gvardiol’s cross, with VAR allowing the goal after Patrick Dorgu’s foot kept the striker onside.
Manchester United player ratings vs Manchester City
Senne Lammens – 6/10
Lammens made useful saves early and handled City’s pressure calmly. Haaland’s finish gave him little chance, while his distribution helped United move forward.
Diogo Dalot – 4/10
Dalot struggled on the flank and lost several duels. His positioning failed United when City’s decisive cross arrived.
Harry Maguire – 5/10
Maguire won headers and dealt with crosses. His booking added pressure in the second half.
Lisandro Martínez – 6/10
Martínez defended aggressively and made important interceptions. He remained one of United’s steadier defenders.
Patrick Dorgu – 5/10
Dorgu pushed forward without producing enough quality. City targeted his side, and his foot later played Haaland onside.
Youri Tielemans – 4/10
Tielemans failed to control midfield despite the extra man. He left in the 66th minute.
Kobbie Mainoo – 6/10
Mainoo showed neat touches and carried the ball through pressure. He worked hard and hit the post, although his influence faded late on.
Manchester United player ratings vs Manchester City attack
Bryan Mbeumo – 5/10
Mbeumo tracked back well and helped Dalot, yet his attacking output remained low.
Bruno Fernandes – 5/10
Fernandes drew the foul that brought Foden’s dismissal and demanded urgency. His passing lacked accuracy near the box.
Marcus Rashford – 4/10
Rashford struck the post early in the second half, but then drifted out of the game. United needed more before his 82nd-minute exit.
Matheus Cunha – 5/10
Cunha dropped deep to link play and fired a half-volley over. He struggled against City’s packed centre and faded late.
Benjamin Šeško – 5/10
Šeško replaced Tielemans after 66 minutes and offered a clearer target.
Joshua Zirkzee – N/A
Zirkzee replaced Rashford in the 82nd minute and barely had time to influence proceedings.
Manchester United player ratings vs Manchester City expose a costly failure
United should have punished City after the red card, yet their attack became predictable, and City defended with discipline. Mainoo and Rashford hit the woodwork, but United lacked the final pass to force an equaliser.
Michael Carrick’s side controlled territory for long spells, but crosses landed in crowded areas, and City survived without losing shape. United had the advantage, yet could not turn it into a goal.
